Are We Obsessed With Protein? A Helpful, Down-to-Earth Look at the Hype

Walk down any supermarket aisle and you’ll see it: protein-boosted everything. Chips, cereal, chocolate bars, yoghurts, ice cream, even water. It feels like we’ve collectively decided protein is the magic answer to health, weight loss, and longevity.

But is this cultural obsession actually helping us – or just giving food companies a new buzzword to plaster on ultra-processed products?

Let’s unpack the hype, the reality, and where protein genuinely earns its spotlight.

---

Where the Protein Obsession Is (Unfortunately) Real

There’s no denying it: the food environment is loud about protein.

• High-protein labels are everywhere, especially on snacks, bars, shakes and cereals.

• Many of these products are still ultra-processed, high in sweeteners, additives, and saturated fat. The protein doesn’t magically turn them into health foods.

• In most high-income countries, people already meet or exceed the basic protein requirement of around 0.8 g per kg of bodyweight per day.

• For sedentary adults, that basic recommendation is usually enough, so chasing more, more, more isn’t always necessary.

In other words: yes, we’re obsessed, and no, extra protein in a doughnut doesn’t make it a wellness snack.

---

Where Higher Protein Actually Is Helpful

The problem isn’t protein itself. Protein is essential. And for some people, higher intakes are genuinely beneficial – not just trendy.

Athletes and Very Active People

Research consistently supports higher protein intakes (around 1.2–2.0 g/kg/day) to aid muscle repair, performance, and adaptation.

Older Adults

As we age, maintaining muscle mass becomes harder. A higher-protein pattern helps protect mobility and strength.

People in Calorie Deficits (weight-loss programs)

More protein helps preserve lean mass, supports satiety, and stabilises energy levels.

Crucially, the quality of protein matters. Whole-food sources – beans, lentils, lean meats, fish, yoghurt, tofu, eggs – tend to bring other nutrients along for the ride, unlike many “protein-enhanced” products with long ingredient lists.

---

The Downsides of the Current Protein Trend

Even though protein has its place, our cultural fixation can bring some unintended pitfalls:

1. It pulls focus from overall diet quality.

People may prioritise high-protein marketing over fibre, plants, whole grains, and minimally processed foods, which most of us need more of.

2. It encourages over-reliance on animal and ultra-processed products.

This can raise intakes of saturated fats and additives and increase environmental impact.

3. “More is better” isn’t ideal for everyone.

Very high protein intakes may be problematic for individuals with, or at risk of, chronic kidney disease. Blanket advice doesn’t work for clinical or vulnerable groups.

---

So… Should You Worry About Your Protein Intake?

If you’re a generally healthy, moderately active adult…

You probably don’t need to chase huge protein numbers or stock your kitchen with protein-fortified snacks. Focus on:

• Getting a moderate, consistent amount of protein at each meal.

• Eating plenty of plants, fibre, and minimally processed foods.

• Choosing whole-food protein sources more often than not.

If you’re strength training, an older adult, or on a weight loss plan:

A higher protein range is important, just don’t fall into the trap of thinking protein bars are better than real meals.

The priorities should be:

• Spreading protein through the day.

• Eating mixed, whole-food sources.

• Ensuring the rest of the diet supports health, not just muscle retention.

---

Final Thoughts

Protein is important, but it’s not a miracle nutrient, and more isn’t always better. Instead of buying into the marketing hype, aim for a balanced, minimally processed diet with sensible protein at each meal.

Your body doesn’t need the latest protein-pumped snack. It needs nourishment, variety and consistency.